Skip to content

Open Mon-Tue: 11:30-8PM/ Wed 2:30 to 8PM/ Thur: 11:30-8PM/ Fri -Sun: 11:30-9pm 📍402 Spadina Ave, Toronto. ☎️ 437-363-3736

  • Shop All
  • Pieces
    • Under 100 PIECES
    • 99 &100 PIECES
    • 275 Pieces
    • 300 Pieces
    • 350 PIECES
    • 500 Pieces
    • 1000 PIECES
    • 2000 PIECES
    • 3000+++ PIECES
    • 1500 PIECES
  • Brands
    • RAVENSBURGER
    • GALISON
    • LAURENCE KING
    • EUROGRAPHICS
    • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY
    • COBBLE HILL
    • VILLAGER
    • Pomegranate
    • HEYE
    • PIATNIK
    • PAPERBLANKS
    • White Mountain Puzzles
    • Holiyay
    • JUMBO
    • CLEMENTONI
    • AQUARIUS
    • ELEWHITE
    • Happily
    • Arts & Farble puzzle
    • MUDPUPPY
    • RIDLEY'S
    • EEBOO
    • ARCADIA PUZZLE
    • MANGO PUZZLE
    • ODD PIECES
    • SCHMIDT
    • Brass Monkey
    • ROCK SAWS
    • Enjoy
    • Pierre Belvedere
    • Trefl
    • Chronicle Books
    • The Paperhood
    • FALCON
  • Kids
    • Age 18M+
    • Age 2+
    • Age 3+
    • Age 4+
    • Age 5+
    • Age 6+
    • Age 7+
    • Age 8+
    • Age 9+
  • NEW!
  • Accessories
Log in

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
  • Instagram
PUZZLE MART
  • Shop All
  • Pieces
    • Under 100 PIECES
    • 99 &100 PIECES
    • 275 Pieces
    • 300 Pieces
    • 350 PIECES
    • 500 Pieces
    • 1000 PIECES
    • 2000 PIECES
    • 3000+++ PIECES
    • 1500 PIECES
  • Brands
    • RAVENSBURGER
    • GALISON
    • LAURENCE KING
    • EUROGRAPHICS
    • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY
    • COBBLE HILL
    • VILLAGER
    • Pomegranate
    • HEYE
    • PIATNIK
    • PAPERBLANKS
    • White Mountain Puzzles
    • Holiyay
    • JUMBO
    • CLEMENTONI
    • AQUARIUS
    • ELEWHITE
    • Happily
    • Arts & Farble puzzle
    • MUDPUPPY
    • RIDLEY'S
    • EEBOO
    • ARCADIA PUZZLE
    • MANGO PUZZLE
    • ODD PIECES
    • SCHMIDT
    • Brass Monkey
    • ROCK SAWS
    • Enjoy
    • Pierre Belvedere
    • Trefl
    • Chronicle Books
    • The Paperhood
    • FALCON
  • Kids
    • Age 18M+
    • Age 2+
    • Age 3+
    • Age 4+
    • Age 5+
    • Age 6+
    • Age 7+
    • Age 8+
    • Age 9+
  • NEW!
  • Accessories

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
Log in Cart

Item added to your cart

View cart

Free in-store pickup available. Enjoy free shipping on orders over $69 🚚 Only $9.99 flat rate shipping across Canada.

Remove all

229 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

229 products

Remove all
Remove all

229 products

  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Tourist Season, 1000 pcs, (Sept 5, 1994) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Tourist Season, 1000 pcs, (Sept 5, 1994)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Tourist Season, 1000 pcs, (Sept 5, 1994)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Tourist Season, 1000 pcs, (Sept 5, 1994)

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Skiing Express, 500 pcs, (Jan 24, 1942) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Skiing Express, 500 pcs, (Jan 24, 1942)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Skiing Express, 500 pcs, (Jan 24, 1942)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Skiing Express, 500 pcs, (Jan 24, 1942)

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sugar Snow, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sugar Snow, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sugar Snow, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sugar Snow, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Homeward, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Homeward, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Homeward, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Homeward, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, At Midnight, 750 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, At Midnight, 750 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, At Midnight, 750 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, At Midnight, 750 pcs

    Regular price $33.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $33.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Tricks & Treats, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Tricks & Treats, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Tricks & Treats, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Tricks & Treats, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Hollow, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Hollow, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Hollow, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Hollow, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Dogs of Halloween, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Dogs of Halloween, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Dogs of Halloween, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Dogs of Halloween, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Perfect Gift, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Perfect Gift, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Perfect Gift, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, The Perfect Gift, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Winter Page-Turners Mini, 100 pcs, (Dec 20 & 27, 2004) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Winter Page-Turners Mini, 100 pcs, (Dec 20 & 27, 2004)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Winter Page-Turners Mini, 100 pcs, (Dec 20 & 27, 2004)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Winter Page-Turners Mini, 100 pcs, (Dec 20 & 27, 2004)

    Regular price $19.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $19.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Home for the Holidays Mini, 100 pcs (Dec,21 1946) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Home for the Holidays Mini, 100 pcs (Dec,21 1946)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Home for the Holidays Mini, 100 pcs (Dec,21 1946)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Home for the Holidays Mini, 100 pcs (Dec,21 1946)

    Regular price $19.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $19.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Winter Palace, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Winter Palace, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Winter Palace, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Winter Palace, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Maximalist Christmas, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Maximalist Christmas, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Maximalist Christmas, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Maximalist Christmas, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas at Orchard House, 1500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas at Orchard House, 1500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas at Orchard House, 1500 pcs

    Sold out

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas at Orchard House, 1500 pcs

    Regular price $49.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $49.99 CAD
    Sold out
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Balloon Ride, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Balloon Ride, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Balloon Ride, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Balloon Ride, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Market, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Market, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Market, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Christmas Market, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, New York Underdogs, 750 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, New York Underdogs, 750 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, New York Underdogs, 750 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, New York Underdogs, 750 pcs

    Regular price $37.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $37.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Parenthood, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Parenthood, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Parenthood, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Parenthood, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sweet Dreams, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sweet Dreams, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sweet Dreams, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Sweet Dreams, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Casserole, 500 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Casserole, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Casserole, 500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Casserole, 500 pcs

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Christmas Avenue, 500 pcs (DEC,15 2025) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Christmas Avenue, 500 pcs (DEC,15 2025)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Christmas Avenue, 500 pcs (DEC,15 2025)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Christmas Avenue, 500 pcs (DEC,15 2025)

    Regular price $32.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $32.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Cats in December, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Cats in December, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Cats in December, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Cats in December, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $39.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $39.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Market Town, 1500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Market Town, 1500 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Market Town, 1500 pcs

    Regular price $49.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $49.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Saturday Pancakes, 300 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Saturday Pancakes, 300 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Saturday Pancakes, 300 pcs

    Sold out

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Saturday Pancakes, 300 pcs

    Regular price $37.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $37.99 CAD
    Sold out
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Coney Island Express, 300 pcs (Sept 5,2011) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Coney Island Express, 300 pcs (Sept 5,2011)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Coney Island Express, 300 pcs (Sept 5,2011)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Coney Island Express, 300 pcs (Sept 5,2011)

    Regular price $37.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $37.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Cannonball, 300 pcs (Oct 20,2025) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Cannonball, 300 pcs (Oct 20,2025)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Cannonball, 300 pcs (Oct 20,2025)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Cannonball, 300 pcs (Oct 20,2025)

    Regular price $37.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $37.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Festival of Lights, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Festival of Lights, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Festival of Lights, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $39.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $39.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Costume Ball, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Costume Ball, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Costume Ball, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $39.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $39.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, The Playground, 1500 pcs (Aug 31, 1940)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, The Playground, 1500 pcs (Aug 31, 1940)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, The Playground, 1500 pcs (Aug 31, 1940)

    Regular price $49.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $49.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Apple Pie Parade Mini, 100 pcs (July,7 1975) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Apple Pie Parade Mini, 100 pcs (July,7 1975)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Apple Pie Parade Mini, 100 pcs (July,7 1975)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Apple Pie Parade Mini, 100 pcs (July,7 1975)

    Regular price $19.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $19.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Circus Parade, 1000 pcs NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Circus Parade, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Circus Parade, 1000 pcs

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, Circus Parade, 1000 pcs

    Regular price $34.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $34.99 CAD
  • NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Old Haunts, 1000 pcs(Oct 31,2022) NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Old Haunts, 1000 pcs(Oct 31,2022)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Old Haunts, 1000 pcs(Oct 31,2022)

    NEW YORK PUZZLE COMPANY, THE NEW YORKER, Old Haunts, 1000 pcs(Oct 31,2022)

    Regular price $39.99 CAD
    Regular price Sale price $39.99 CAD
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 8

Quick links

  • Shipping Policy
  • Return Policy

CONTACT US

Email us at Info@puzzlemart.ca

402 Spadina Ave, Toronto ON

Subscribe to our emails

  • Instagram

Country/region

  • Canada CAD $
  • United States USD $
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2026, PUZZLE MART Powered by Shopify
  • Privacy policy
  • Refund policy
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.